به قول معروف يک کلمه
به قول معروف يک کلمه هم از مادر عروس. حسين درخشان پس از نظريهپردازیهایش در باب مسايل مختلف حالا مدافع نظری فمينيسم شده و به مطلب سيما در نقد نوشته من اين طوری لينک داده است : «نقد یک آکادمیسین بر کسی که فکر میکند فمینیزم را نقد کرده است» با اين توضيح که «از کسی که تنها به زبان فارسی راجع به فمینیزم خوانده است چه انتظاری است». بيچاره حسين درخشان که بر خلاف من خيلی انگليسی میداند هنوز فرق فمينيست و فمينيسم را نمیداند و گرنه اگر به تيتر مطلب من دقت میکرد میفهمید که چه گفتهام. «نقدی کوچک بر فمينيستها» يعنی نقدی بر نحوه رفتار کسانی که طرفدار مکتب فمينيسم هستند و اين هيچ ربطی به نقد «فمينيسم به عنوان يک مکتب فکري» ندارد. تازه فکر کنم بنده خدا اصلا محتوای مطلب من را نخوانده يا آن را نفهميده که فکر میکند من سعی کردهام فمينيسم را نقد کنم.
نظرات
s :
در مقامِ مفتی و دانای کلّ عرض میکنم: اصلاً حتی نگاه به تیترهای ایشان هم محلِ اشکال است، چه رسد به جواب دادن. اثباتِ زبانندانیشان هم دونِ شأنِ جای محترمی مثلِ اینجا است (النهایة میشود در همان محل که ایشان چیز منتشر میکند سطری نوشت)؛ بنده خوفِ آن دارم—و نشانههایی در همین مطلب میبینم—که لحنشان شدیداْ واگیر باشد. اعتنا نکنید و کارتان را بکنید. موفق باشید.
s - September 28, 2005 03:48 PM
کامران :
ممکنه شما تفاوت فمینیزم و فمینیست را بیان کنید ما هم آشنا بشیم؟!
کامران - September 29, 2005 02:48 AM
Sahand :
se: Civilizations that indulge in excessive isothymia, that fanatically seeks to eliminate every manifestation of unequal recognition, will quickly run into limits imposed by nature itself. Even two siblings at the same home are different. One might have an interest in serious literature, mathematic, philosophy, hard science and the other in sport or at anything at all. Trying to make these two individual equal is the worst kind of aggression toward a human being . Soviet system killed the desire, the engine of history. When a doctor after ten years of hard study was getting paid almost as much as a worker that was drunk Monday - Friday and all weekend, people started not to study and not to work hard.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:09 AM
Sahand :
dou: These laws and regulation were adopted either to counter act ex Soviet Union’s claim --to hinder, slow down the socialist idea within Westerners or were just fair laws to be adopted.
Ex Soviet triumph was enormous and helped American to wake up after launching first and successful launching of Sputnik—the world first artificial satellite--. Their success in Nuclear, quantum physics, biology, pure and applied mathematics, space programs were just outstanding. Marxism was married to science and Soviet Union depended on it. In spite of all these wonderful success socialism failed for a couple simple reasons, Internal conflicts, and external pressures. But it failed largely due to its own internal contradiction. Marxism fanatically pursued what is called Isothymia--- equality---.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:09 AM
Sahand :
Yek: “ Ever since puberty I have believed in the value of two things; kindness and clear thinking. At first these two reminded more or less distinct; when I felt triumphant I believed most in clear thinking, and in the opposite mood believed most in kindness. Gradually the two come more and more together in my feelings. I find that much unclear thought exists as an excuse for cruelty, and that much cruelty is prompted by superstitious beliefs. --- Bertrand Russell, Autobiography---
Comparison of Marxism and feminism:
Just a couple weeks ago according to BBC, in pull large number of British thinkers thought that Marx was the brightest mind that ever been there. No one can deny the genius of Marx and some of his followers. Socialism may be out of fashion but almost all of these days so called progressive laws in Western countries are the result of Marx and his ideas.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:09 AM
Sahand :
panj: Second: the only things that have and is and will help women to advance,--- mainly science and technology--- is alien to feminist leaders. They are talking about feminist biology, feminist geometry feminist science and in general feminist version of every thing we have, as if light would travel slower in feminist way of seeing the things. There is nothing wrong to have a wish but the problem is that they want to build a skyscraper over sandy and shaky foundation.
I would gave a prize to any one naming even single feminist mathematician, scientist etc. The last commander of space shuttle was a woman not a feminist. Her husband is a medical doctor and in an interview, she said every morning we leave home just by saying, “ see you”. She is so involved with her job that does not have time to show any emption, she deserve to be a leader and not Andrea Dworkin and other assistance professor in women study or literature.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:10 AM
Sahand :
chahar: Socialism was like a sine wave, started at zero and reached its zenith at 90 degree and then some flatness and then rapid decline, because people were not interested in bringing new energy into the life. and that is exactly what Marxism did in ex Soviet Union. Human pursue megalothymia, every one wants to be the best whether it is in art, or science or trade. The conductor conducting the Beethoven symphony is as megalothymic as the daredevil jumper or a racecar driver.
The second major factor helping the rapid collapse of Soviet system was their involvement with arm race. It was like a poor child getting into competition with a rich one, trying to buy what ever the others have.
Feminism have every characteristic of Marxism with two exceptions. Feminism had not and will not generate anyone in caliber of Max, Lenin and other great thinkers and organizers.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:10 AM
Sahand :
shesh: Women should follow her and not the lazy, stuffed feminist sucking people’s money by getting large grants solving so called “ women” issues.”
Note: Understanding the psychological differences between men and women would take years. My experience with my own son and daughter has proven that what Freud and Lacan have said about male and female psyche formation is absolutely true. I treated them equally, never bought my daughter any thing in pink color. They had the same bicycle, the same toys, but not dolls. They took the same Karate classes--- my daughter was 5 and son 9--- but they grow up totally different. One is hooked on computer, and technology and the other loves animals and painting.
Sahand - September 29, 2005 04:11 AM
mehdi :
تا حالا یک بار ندیدم این یارو به حرفی بزنه و ضایع نکنه.
mehdi - September 29, 2005 12:15 PM
AmirT :
bichaare HoDer ke paa az gelim e khod (ya'ni omoor e fanni e marboot be weblog-saazi) faraa nahaade va baa bad-akhlaaqi haa sh hamegaan raa az khod raande
AmirT - September 29, 2005 03:47 PM
حامد قدوسی :
کامران عزیز جدی گفتی یا شوخی؟ فرض می کنم شوخی نکردی. فرق فمینیسم و فمینیست مثل تفاوت ایسم و ایست در هر مکتب دیگری است. اولی به خود مکتب اشاره می کند مثل مارکسیسم و لیبرالیسم و دومی به کسی که طرفدار آن مکتب است مثل مارکسیست و لیبرالیست. ولی فکر کنم خواستی من را دست بیندازی :)
حامد قدوسی - September 29, 2005 03:51 PM